Pegasus Hacking Scandal_0

 

The Modi Government’s use of Israeli “Pegasus” spyware technology to secretly and illegally hack into and take control of the phones of thousands of Opposition leaders, journalists, Supreme Court judges, activists and other Indian citizens is by far the biggest criminal act by a Government in 75 years of independent India.

Investigations by the Paris-based non-profit ‘Forbidden Stories’ as well as Amnesty International have been verified and simultaneously published by reputed media organisations around the world. These investigations establish that the Israeli firm NSO sells Pegasus software only to governments, ostensibly for “national security” and “counter-terrorism” purposes. Pegasus can be used to hack into smartphones remotely, and then gain control over those smartphones, without the knowledge of the target. Media organisations conducted forensic analysis of phones belonging to those whose numbers figured on the list of targeted numbers. This forensic analysis has conclusively established that not only was Pegasus used in 2017-18 to target Opposition leaders, journalists, judges, lawyers, activists of student movements, workers movements, human rights defenders and other individuals – Pegasus continues to be active on the current phone sets of several of those targets.

The targets include leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi and his closest aides; Trinamool Congress leader Mamata Banerjee’s nephew Abhishek Banerjee; election strategist Prashant Kishore; Congress and JD(S) leaders in Karnataka; a sitting Supreme Court judge; a large number of journalists (editors as well as reporters); and a large number of activists.

Pegasus has been found active on Prashant Kishore’s phone currently, which indicates that he was a target for hacking during the recent West Bengal elections in which he was the election strategist for the BJP’s rival Trinamool Congress. The numbers of key Congress and JD(S) leaders of Karnataka were reportedly added to the list of targets just prior to collapse of the Congress-JD(S) coalition government, paving the way for the BJP to capture power. Here, the question arises – was the Modi government using Pegasus technology purchased at a steep cost to the taxpayers, to target its political rivals to benefit the ruling BJP party? If so there can be no greater instance of political corruption.

The most shocking and blatant act of criminality is the inclusion of the Supreme Court staffer who accused Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi of sexual harassment, and 11 of her family members in the list. Phones belonging to members of this particular family were selected for targeting days after one of them filed a sexual harassment complaint against CJI Gogoi. This raises the question: was the government of India hacking into the phones of a sexual harassment complainant and her family members in order to be able to stalk and intimidate them as well as snoop on their legal strategy? Was this done to protect the accused Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi – and if so was any deal struck with the CJI in exchange? What was the impact of these actions on crucial Supreme Court judgments in which the Government had a special interest?

In its defence the Modi Government says that the UPA tapped phones too. But there is a legal infrastructure governing phone taps: phones can be tapped by the government in exceptional circumstances relating to national security, but only with a range of checks and balances which ensure that the order permitting the phone taps are sent to a Review Committee within a week. If the UPA violated these rules in its tenure, why has the Modi regime not pursued those cases and punished the offenders? Pegasus is used to hack phones, not tap them – and hacking is a criminal offence in India.

The Modi Government further says there is no proof linking Pegasus to the BJP or its government; however, it has not categorically denied purchasing and deploying Pegasus. NSO says that it sells only to governments. But if some non-government entity purchased and used Pegasus against Indian citizens, why is the Modi Government not interested in identifying and punishing this entity? Why is it not interested in protecting Indian citizens from such an entity? Why is it treating the Pegasus revelations as a non-issue?

According to 2016 estimates, the NSO’s charge for spying on just 10 people using Pegasus was around Rs 9 crore. The recent revelations show that Pegasus was used to hack into some 1500 phones in India in 2017-18. Presumably this number only increased in the years since 2018 till the present. Have Indian taxpayers (suffering demonetisation; joblessness; rises in food and fuel prices; and lockdowns) been footing the bill for this massive crime? How has this expense been disguised in the accounts? How was the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) office prevented from noticing such a massive expense?

A Government which hacked into phones of judges, journalists, Opposition leaders and activists could potentially stalk and blackmail these individuals or threaten their lives to silence them or to extract favours from them. It could plant evidence on their phones in order to frame them: as in the Bhima Koregaon case where Pegasus was used to target the accused. It could keep track of the strategies of Opposition politicians; and use knowledge obtained through hacking to topple Opposition governments and buy Opposition MLAs. It could be pre-warned of every journalistic investigation, so that it could destroy evidence in advance.

In other words, the list of targets indicates that Pegasus was used, not for any purpose of governance or national security, but simply to serve the private interests of the ruling party or some of its leaders. In the USA’s Watergate episode, President Nixon was forced to resign for planting bugs to listen in on a Convention of the opposition party. The use of Pegasus in India is a crime of far greater proportions than Watergate – and demands investigation and punishment.

Did the Modi regime purchase Pegasus during Prime Minister Modi’s visit to Israel in 2017? Did it deploy Pegasus to try and control every branch of India’s democracy: the political Opposition; the judiciary; the press; and civil society? Why does the Government not tell the people: did they, or did they not, purchase and deploy Pegasus? If they did not, who did? Indian citizens deserve answers to these questions.

If the Government hacked our phones, it is an attack on the Constitution and the rights of Indian citizens. If some other force hacked our phones, then it is truly a threat to national security and the security of India’s citizens. The fact that an Israeli company has access to thousands of India’s citizens including journalists and judges, is in any case a serious breach of national security.

An independent tribunal must be empowered to seek time-bound answers from the Modi government and its functionaries at every level, so as to ensure that those responsible for the criminal use of Pegasus are identified and prosecuted.